The excavation site’s close proximity to a critical road and active runaways wasn’t even the biggest challenge for Midwest REM; it was the restrictions on overhead space.
Underground Utility Contractor Midwest REM, based in Melrose Park, IL, recently completed casting-in-place a new stormwater pump station at O’Hare International Airport. The new pump station is a subproject of the multi-year, multimillion-dollar O’Hare Modernization Program.
The 7,500-gallon-per-minute structure measured 60 feet wide, 60 feet long, and 35 feet tall. Adding to the excavation project’s already challenging parameters was the fact that the behemoth pump station needed to be tucked-in between an adjacent road and a nearby active runaway. Surprisingly, however, the limited space around the excavation site was not the biggest challenge facing the contractor.
We’ve put together this handy guide to cover “rent vs. lease vs. buy” questions. Included are three decision trees along with a recap of pros and cons of each option. How to Choose Between Rent vs. Buy. Download it now!
Shoring Options Limited Due to Overhead Restrictions
“The biggest challenge on this project was headspace,” says Walter Murphy, Midwest REM’s project superintendent. “Working at one of the busiest airports in the world, the Federal Aviation Administration will only allow you to go so high with your equipment. Even though there are no overhead obstacles like powerlines; the flying planes are the overhead obstacles.”
With an excavation the size needed to form and pour the jumbo concrete structure, shoring options are limited. Tight sheeting is usually the first shoring system considered for such a large excavation, but because of the strict project parameters, sheeting was not going to work.
“The height restriction meant we couldn’t drive sheeting to shore the excavation, or we would need to drive the sheets at night,” says Murphy. “But if we tried to open cut and slope, we’d have a hole as big as China.”
Midwest REM needed a safe and cost-effective shoring alternative to tight sheeting or open-cut.
Contractor Chooses Efficiency Slide Rail System Over Tight-Sheeting
With tight sheeting ruled out, Murphy called local shoring equipment distributor Trench Plate Rental to enquire about using an Efficiency Production manufactured Slide Rail Shoring System. “We chose Slide Rail because it was the only shoring system that would work with the limited space between runaways and roads and flying planes,” he says.
Efficiency’s Universal Slide Rail System is a component shoring system comprised of steel panels—similar to trench shield sidewalls—and vertical steel posts. When installed, the versatile system creates a safe, obstruction-free shored excavation. Efficiency’s ClearSpan System uses the universal Slide Rail components to shore large excavations with dimensions as large as 60 x 60 feet or more. In a linear Multi-Bay configuration, long pipelines can be shored with a set number of slide rail components; a significant cost savings when installing pipe or other utilities over great distances.
“The Slide Rail System worked very well,” says Murphy. “I would definitely use the system again for a job with space limits like we had.”
Midwest rented enough Slide Rail equipment to install a 63 x 63 x 32 foot system. It is installed simultaneously as the trench or pit is excavated by sliding the panels into integrated rails on the posts–an outside slotted rail first, then an open-face rail on the inside–then pushing the panels and posts incrementally down to grade as the pit is dug, a process commonly referred to as a “dig and push” system.
To assist Midwest with installation, manufacturer Efficiency Production sent from their Special Operations Shoring Division senior Slide Rail Installer and shoring specialist, Dan Meredith. “The ClearSpan was a challenging pit to put in,” he admits. “Fortunately, Midwest REM’s foreman on the job had installed Slide Rail before, and his crew was patient and willing to try different techniques to keep the system moving down.”
The Midwest REM personnel were very complimentary of Meredith’s experience installing Slide Rail and the direction he provided to their crew. Midwest installed the entire Slide Rail system with: a John Deere 450 excavator, a Kobelco SK170 excavator that was lifted into the system to dig under the posts and panels, a Terex hydraulic truck crane with a maximum height of 38 feet to set the Slide Rail linear posts, and a John Deere 624 wheel loader that supplied the excavator with Slide Rail panels and other equipment while also moving dirt away from the excavation.
Founded in 1994, Midwest REM is a Chicago-based minority contractor. The company was subcontracted for this project by Chicago-based general contractor Kenny Construction. The engineering firm was DH Charles Civil Engineering.