The Olive Question

  • Email This Post Email This Post

Sometimes the choice between technologies isn’t clear. A new technique or an improved process saves us something in one area, but has a potential cost somewhere else. How to weigh the differences?

Scientists at the University of California, Davis, have come up with a new way to perform a basic task that goes back thousands of years: preparing olives. To make them edible, raw olives have traditionally been soaked first in a solution of brine and then in a solution of lye (sodium hydroxide) to remove bitter compounds called phenols. The soaking liquid must be changed a number of times; as this Economist article notes, “This is tedious, messy, and generates phenol-rich waste that is toxic to plants and animals.”

The Metropolitan Water Reclamation District of Greater Chicago is seeking a visionary Executive Director. The District is an award-winning wastewater agency which has been a leader in protecting the Chicago area water environment for over a 120 years. For information and to apply, click here or contact [email protected]The District is an Equal Opportunity Employer.

The UC Davis researchers are now replacing the lye solution with hollowed-out polystyrene beads. When added to a vat of soaking olives, the beads’ ion-exchange properties allow them to capture phenols from the brine solution. The beads achieve essentially the same result—olives that are not bitter—without the use of lye and without the extra time usually required to soak the olives in a separate lye solution. If the process can be scaled up for commercial use, it would mean faster processing time and cheaper olives.

The beads have high porosity and, because they’re hollow, a high surface-to-volume ratio, so they’re efficient at capturing the phenols. One type of bead tested has already been approved by the Food and Drug Administration as being safe for use in preparing food.

So what’s the trade-off? Polystyrene is a kind of plastic; one form is trademarked as Styrofoam—the packing and food-container material that so many environmental groups have been trying to ban—and polystyrene items are present in large amounts in waterways in the form of disposable plastic utensils, cups, yogurt containers, and so on. It does not easily biodegrade, but it does break down into smaller pieces that are easily eaten by birds, fish, and other water-dwelling creatures, making its way into the food chain. There is already widespread concern about microbeads—now banned in cosmetic products in the US and several other countries—and nurdles, the tiny plastic beads used to manufacture plastic bags and other products.

The UC Davis researchers say the phenols can be removed from the polystyrene beads they’re using with the olives, and the beads themselves can be recycled or reused, which would at least temporarily solve the problem of what to do with the beads. So here is my question for the chemists out there: What’s the process for removing phenols from polystyrene, and how much water does it take? Is the disposal of the wastewater from that process less hazardous—or less expensive, or both—than the disposal process for the traditional lye solution? SW_bug_web

Related Posts


  1. Thanks for asking those question; UC Davis has brought us a litany of agricultural “improvements” over the decades, many of which have revealed themselves as environmental disasters over time.
    The last thing we need on this planet right now is more plastic.

    1. Jeff,
      We certainly don’t need more plastic in the waste stream. I believe the questions we should asking pertain to whether or not this new process is an environmental improvement to the current process. From what I read in the article, the polystyrene beads might conceivably be reused or recycled, at lower environmental costs than using lye. Olives are a valuable crop that doesn’t require summer irrigation, so let’s see if we can clean the baby instead of throwing it out with the bath water.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *